Major Psychological Theories: A Comparative Analysis

MajorTheoretical Position and Represented InterestsExplanation of the Process/Method of StudyPerceptual Differences with Other Major Subjects of Study
FunctionalismFunctional dimensions of psychological processes as instrumental in adaptation to the environment.W. James, J. Dewey, J. R. Angell used several methods: introspection, experimental method, comparative method, etc.Motivational factors, personal interest in adaptation to the environment that affect perception. Perception plays an instrumental role in motivation and emotion. Subject as an active element.
StructuralismSimple elements, attributes, their structures, and laws of combination, to analyze the complex elements.W. Wundt, E. B. Titchener, G. E. Müller used lab analysis.Perception is the result of elementary components (simple elements) perceived as a product of experience. Not innatism.
BehaviorismConduct systematic observation of only observable stimuli and responses.J. B. Watson used observable and controllable stimuli and responses by the experimenter.The study of perception occurred in a second plane. Abandonment of methods of structuralism and functionalism.
School of GestaltHolistic nature, unity, and global mental phenomena. Analysis of simple elements and their combination.M. W. Wertheimer, W. Köhler, K. Koffka used introspection and observation. K. Lewin.Perceive objects as complete structures, configurations, or “all organized,” rather than as isolated and separate parts. Reject the study of parts; perceive totalities. Perceptive laws. Innatism in our brain in perception.
Ecological Theory / Direct PerceptionStudy of stimuli in the environment that are responsible for perception.J. Gibson used observation and experimentation.The richness of perception is given by the richness of the environment, not in thought processes. Perceive the environment directly from the information processing of stimuli down-up. Importance of stimulus. Affordances: the objects that surround us have a certain number of potential uses that are perceived directly, without previous experience.
Information ProcessingIdentification and description of cognitive processes and connecting them through specific patterns of information flow.Broadbent, Simon, Gardner, Neisser used flowcharts.Information perception must be studied together with other mental processes as a single, integrated system. Perception is a system of limited capacity. All processes can be explained in terms of stages or phases.
Computational TheoryStudy of human perceptual systems, especially the visual.D. Marr used simulation of cognitive processes through the computer.Human perceptual systems are based on mathematical models of information processing. Indirect perception. Perceptual processes as mathematical models. Analogy between the mind and the computer. Processing reaches down.
ConstructivismStudy of perceptual processes.H. Von Helmholtz, R. L. Gregory used experimental and objective techniques. Systematic observation.The observer is who builds perceptions based on information from the environment. Active construction. Processing is coming down. Schema (Neisser).