Christ’s Historical Claim: Understanding Through the Gospels
Understanding Christ’s Historical Claim
The Gospels: More Than Mere Records
There is a historical fact that claims to be precisely the realization of the hypothesis presented. We possess a historical document that has reached us, showing how the problem first arose: the Gospels. These Gospels are not (one cannot know an object through the objective method that requires it to be addressed) mere, unrelated transcripts of what Christ said, nor a report on His activities as a police officer might compile.
Read MorePlato’s Theory of Forms: Metaphysics and Epistemology
Plato’s Metaphysics: The Theory of Forms and Knowledge
Plato’s philosophy, particularly his approach to the ‘problem of nature,’ is intrinsically linked to his ethical and political system. For Plato, the world is fundamentally divided into two distinct realms:
The Two Worlds: Intelligible and Sensible
- The World of Ideas (Intelligible World): This is the realm of true being, accessible only through intellect and reason. The Ideas (or Forms) are universal realities, perfect, eternal, and unchanging
Ancient Greek Philosophy: Sophists, Epicurus, and Socrates
The Sophists: Masters of Rhetoric and Relativism
The Sophists were a group of influential thinkers and scholars (Sophos) in ancient Greece, known for their mastery of demagoguery and rhetoric. They dedicated themselves to teaching others, often charging fees for their instruction. Most Sophists were foreigners (metoikoi) residing in Athens.
They asserted that it was not necessary to find a unique and unalterable truth, advocating for:
- The Principle of Isonomia: Equality of all before the law.
- A strong
Nietzsche’s Challenge to Western Thought
The philosophy of Nietzsche involves a radical confrontation with much of the Western tradition. He is opposed to dogmatism, whose roots lie in Socrates, Plato, or Christian philosophy.
The distinction or opposition, made in his earlier works, between the Dionysian and Apollonian leads him to develop an original interpretation of the history of philosophy. According to this view, thought moves away from life, from Socratic reflection, leading him to oppose it, denying it through the invention of
Read MoreCriteria for Truth in Epistemology
Epistemology and Truth Criteria
Epistemology concerns the criteria we use to determine truth.
Criteria in the Plane of Vision
This involves pure speculation:
- Truth in Perception
- Truth in the Trial
Criteria in the Rational Plane
In this rational plane, beliefs or opinions arise, which are often false.
The Criterion of Evidence
Here we must refer to the criterion of intellectual evidence proposed by Descartes, whose components are clarity and distinction.
A different way to formulate the criterion of evidence
Read MoreKey Concepts in Argumentation and Rhetoric
Argumentation vs. Opinion Differences
Argumentation and opinion both involve expressing viewpoints but differ in their foundation and purpose. An opinion is a subjective belief reflecting personal feelings or preferences, often expressed informally and without requiring evidence. In contrast, argumentation aims to persuade through a structured presentation of logical reasons and solid evidence, such as data, expert insights, or statistics, while also addressing counterarguments to strengthen its
Read More