Philosophical Divergence: Plato and Marx on Society
Plato vs. Marx: Political Conceptions Compared
This comparison highlights key similarities and differences in the political conceptions of Plato and Marx.
Similarities and Differences in Political Thought
Social Change Dynamics
Similarity: Both philosophers argue that civil strife, wars, and class divisions, often grounded in selfishness, are the main dynamic forces for social change.
Difference: For Plato, the historical process follows a linear downward trajectory, leading to a deemed necessary hegemonic
Rationalism and Empiricism: Core Philosophical Concepts
Philosophical Orientations of Knowledge
Rationalism
Radical Rationalism
Radical Rationalism defends that only reason provides valid knowledge. Its proponents reject sensory knowledge, believing it to be deceptive, showing only appearances and never true reality. Radical rationalists tend to hold innatist positions, asserting that reason is the fundamental basis of knowledge and that certain components of knowledge are proven a priori (before experience).
Moderate Rationalism
Moderate Rationalists acknowledge
Read MoreFoundations of Political Science: Concepts and Methodology
Political Science, broadly and non-technically, is the study of phenomena and/or political structures. It involves a systematic approach conducted with scientific rigor, supported by a comprehensive review of facts developed on the basis of rational arguments.
Elements for Scientific Rigor in Political Science
For Political Science to be considered a science, it must possess these three elements:
- Orientation of Study: A clear focus for investigation.
- Application to Political Phenomena: The study should
Understanding Core Ethical Theories and Principles
Ethics and Morality: Core Distinctions
Today, morality is often associated with the expression of moral standards (the content of morality), while ethics is considered the philosophical reflection on the criteria of justification for those standards.
Ethics and Law: Defining Boundaries
While ethics is the philosophical reflection on the criteria for justifying various actions, law refers to the established legal framework. It dictates what is permissible or impermissible, regardless of individual ethical
Read MorePlato’s Arguments for Soul Immortality: An Analysis
Plato’s Phaedo: First Argument for Soul Immortality
This argument posits that opposites arise from opposites.
Part I: Theory of Opposites (Contra Heraclitus)
- Introduction 1: Opposites are produced from their contraries.
- Introduction 2: Life and death are contraries.
- Introduction 3: From life, death is produced.
Conclusion:
From death, life will occur.
Plato’s Phaedo: Second Argument, Theory of Reminiscence
This argument recalls the theory of recollection as presented in Plato’s Meno, including the proof
Read MoreAristotle’s Philosophical Foundations: Soul, Ethics, and Governance
While Plato viewed man as an accidental composite of two distinct substances (body and soul), Aristotle presented a unified, spiritual, and non-biological perspective. For Aristotle, man is a single substance, a complete living organism, composed of a body (the subject) and a soul (the form). Aristotelian psychology is organized as follows:
Aristotle’s Anthropology: Body and Soul
Unlike Plato, who believed the soul and body were separable substances, with the soul potentially surviving the body (implying
Read More